Directions: From Uniontown, take the New Salem Road which runs west off Rt. 40 (at the Sheetz Gas Station). Go about 5 miles and at the stop sign in New Salem, turn right onto North Mill Street beyond the PNC Bank which sits on the corner. Go about 1/10 mile to the top of the hill where the former church (now a residence?) sits on the left. The cemetery is behind a garden to the right of the church. Request permission from the owner for access.
GPS Location:
39.92679 N
79.83610 W
| Surname | Given Name(s) | Born | Died | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adams | Joseph E | 7/20/1908 | 10/9/1911 | ||
| Barnes | Amon | 3/9/1852 | 55yr/6mo/3d | 1 | |
| Cain | Sidney A | w/o Levi, 25y/2m/16d | |||
| Coras | George M | 1872 | 1913 | OUR FATHER | |
| Davis | Barbara A | w/o Israel | |||
| Davis | Levi | 6/4/1825 | 1/27/1884 | ||
| Fike | Billy | 3/24/1919 | 3/9/1920 | ||
| Gallagher | Mary Jane Palmer | 9/16/1888 | d/o JE & HA Pamer, 34 years of age | ||
| Gosnell | Namarah Jane | 1/28/1937 | 1 | ||
| Lewis | Elizabeth | 3/8/1868 | d/o FA & PA Lewis, 1yr/1mo/18d | ||
| Lewis | Frances A | 12/10/1824 | 4/6/1903 | ||
| Lewis | Mary | 9/26/1860 | d/o FA & PA Lewis, 1yr/7mo/0d | ||
| Lewis | Phoebe A | 3/2/1830 | 7/20/1887 | ||
| Lilley | Albert W | 9/29/1873 | 1yr/7mo/0d | ||
| Lilley | Andrew J | 2/24/1826 | 7/30/1909 | Father on stone | |
| Lilley | Andrew J | 1/21/1870 | s/o AJ & S, 2yr/8mo/6d | 1 | |
| Lilley | Bartholonew | 3/5/1858 | 61 yrs | 1 | |
| Lilley | Benjamin | 1884 | 1954 | Our father | |
| Lilley | Bertha L | 8/29/1887 | 9/5/1887 | 1 | |
| Lilley | Catherine | 9/23/1878 | w/o AJ, 39 years | 1 | |
| Lilley | Frank | 12/31/1873 | 1yr/1mo/18d | ||
| Lilley | Issac | 1857 | 1938 | ||
| Lilley | Jesse | 1881 | s/o EE & SE Lilly | ||
| Lilley | Laura | 1884 | 1896 | d/o EE & SE Lilly | |
| Lilley | Lili Vernette | 8/23/1898 | d/o BF & MM Lilly, 0y/4mo/15 d | ||
| Lilley | Martha J | 1861 | 1942 | ||
| Lilley | Mary | 3/5/1865 | 2yr/7mo/22d | ||
| Lilley | Myrtle | 6/1/1884 | 10 years | 1 | |
| Lilley | Sarah E | 9/30/1868 | w/o Andrew, 41yr/3mo/18d | 1 | |
| McCormick | William H | 3/9/1852 | 3yr/0mo/15d | 1 | |
| Messmore | Elizabeth Miller | 2/14/1834 | 8/31/1896 | ||
| Miller | Elizabeth Jane | 3/17/1867 | 1888 | d/o Richard & Katy Ann Keener Miller | |
| Miller | Mary Elizabeth Temple | 1800 | 7/18/1866 | w/o Richard Miller, 66 years of living | |
| Miller | Richard | 1802 | 9/17/1877 | ||
| Miller | William Irvin | 2/27/1830 | 5/13/1871 | ||
| Miller | William Jackson | 8/7/1828 | 4/18/1829 | ||
| Orange | Lucinda | 8/25/1893 | w/o Thomas, 59 yrs of age | 1 | |
| Orange | Matilda | 6/28/1876 | w/o Thomas, 40 yrs of age | 1 | |
| Palmer | Flora D | 11/11/1875 | d/o JE & HA Palmer, 14yr/1mo/27d | ||
| Palmer | Hester A | 9/27/1817 | 6/26/1875 | ||
| Palmer | James E | 6/15/1806 | 9/7/1873 | ||
| Palmer | John O | 5/17/1874 | 22yr/8mo | ||
| Pratt | Carl, Jr. | 1946 | 1946 | ||
| Pratt | E. Finley | 1880 | 1962 | ||
| Pratt | Francis | 1885 | 1950 | ||
| Pratt | Helen W | 1915 | 1920 | ||
| Pratt | Issac | 5/9/1837 | 7/2/1899 | GAR | |
| Pratt | John T | 1864 | 1899 | ||
| Pratt | Nellie V | 1915 | 1915 | ||
| Pratt | Rebecca | 3/11/1888 | w/o Issac, 47 yrs | ||
| Price | Rev. Benjamin | 7/11/1862 | 65 yrs | ||
| Sandusky | Robbie | 12/11/1890 | 69yr/0mo/22d | ||
| Savage | Lucretia | 1880 | 1881 | d/o Robinson & Mary | |
| Savage | Maggie M | 1873 | 1949 | ||
| Smith | Sarah | 7/5/1890 | 89 yrs | ||
| Temple | Mrs. Richard | No dates | |||
| Temple | Rev. Richard | No dates | |||
| Thomas | Nora Elizabeth | 1907 | 1922 | d/o W & Elizabeth | |
| White | John | 4/27/1842 | 7/8/1906 | ||
| White | John E | 10/21/1867 | 1 | ||
| White | Lizzie Ann | 7/28/1877 | d/o J & RAA, 7yr/1mo/28d | 1 | |
| White | Lizzie M | 3/1873 | 4/7/1879 | ||
| White | Lulu | 1863(8)? | 1937 | ||
| White | WJ | No dates | 1 | ||
| White | WM | 1871 | 7/8/1906 | ||
| ????? | Lizzie | 3/1882 | 4/1889 | ||
| ????? | Lud(c)retia | 5/18/1887 | 9/5/1888 | ||
| ????? | Infant DADE | 8/1882 | |||
| ????? | David K | 3/12/1862 | 1/2/1885 | The above 4 on one stone | |
| ????? | Ruth E | 4/2/1905 | 10/14/1906 | d/o JM & Namara, at rest | |
| (1) | Stones read by Della Reagan Fischer prior to 1971 that are no longer standing or legible. |